NCAA Division III Tournament Appearances (17)
- 1989 Second Round (South Atlantic Regional, third place)
- 1992 Sweet 16
- 1994 Sweet 16
- 1995 Elite Eight
- 1997 First Round
- 1998 Sweet 16
- 1999 National Finalist / Final Four
- 2000 Second Round
- 2001 Second Round
- 2002 Second Round
- 2003 Final Four
- 2004 Second Round
- 2007 Second Round
- 2013 First Round
- 2023 Second Round
- 2024 National Finalist / Final Four
- 2025 Sweet 16
ODAC Championships (11)
- 1989
- 1992
- 1995
- 1997
- 1998
- 1999
- 2001
- 2002
- 2004
- 2007
- 2024
Gammon Cup Winners (35)
The Gammon Cup is awarded annually to the student-athlete in the graduating class who has best served the College. It is given in memory of Dr. Edgar G. Gammon, former pastor of College Church (1917-23) and President of the College (1939-55), and recipients are considered for their character, scholarship and athletic ability. Please note that the Gammon Cup was not awarded from 1944-46 due to World War II.
- 1924 Harold Dudley
- 1925 E.M. Sager
- 1930 R.W Lawson
- 1931 L.L. Price
- 1932 E.L. Kendig, Jr.
- 1936 W.S. Formwalt
- 1939 W. Taylor Reveley
- 1940 Bennett Barnes, Jr.
- 1943 Frank E. Taylor
- 1947 William L. Harvie
- 1948 George J. Kostel
- 1950 Edward W. Sharp
- 1951 Alfred A. Adkins, III
- 1952 A. Emerson Johnson
- 1953 Frank Hoffman
- 1966 Frank M. Booth III
- 1967 James Rosenstock
- 1972 Tommy Moore
- 1979 Thomas Jackson
- 1983 Timothy McGarry
- 1989 Ralph Baker
- 1992 Russell Turner
- 1995 Jason Leonard
- 1999 David Hobbs
- 2000 Jack Jirak
- 2004 Jeff Monroe
- 2006 Matt Guill
- 2007 Matt Green
- 2008 Drew Prehmus
- 2011 Colin O'Neill
- 2014 Khobi Williamson
- 2016 Mike Murray
- 2017 Jake Duncan
- 2018 Guilherme Guimaraes
- 2024 Josiah Hardy
- 2025 Adam Brazil
All-Americans (12) | NABC All-America Archives | D3hoops.com All-America Archives
- 1952 - Emerson Johnson
- 1963 - Bill Hardin
- 1989 - Ralph Baker
- 1991 - Russell Turner (USBWA Second Team)
- 1992 - Russell Turner (NABC First Team)
- 1995 - Nate Schwab (DIII News Fourth Team)
- 2000 - T.J. Grimes (NABC First Team / D3hoops.com Second Team)
- 2003 - Jeff Monroe (NABC Second Team / D3hoops.com Second Team)
- 2004 - Jeff Monroe (D3hoops.com First Team)
- 2024 - Davidson Hubbard (NABC Second Team / D3hoops.com Third Team)
- 2024 - Adam Brazil (NABC Third Team)
- 2025 - Adam Brazil (NABC First Team / D3hoops.com First Team)
CoSIDA/CSC Academic All-Americans (7)
The College Sports Information Directors of America (CoSIDA) began the Academic All-America program in 1952. The organization is now known as College Sports Communicators (CSC). To be eligible for this prestigious award: student-athletes must be at least a sophomore academically and athletically; student-athletes must be enrolled at their institution at the time of nomination either as undergraduates or graduate students. Only the school at which an athlete competed in the current academic year can nominate that player; an undergraduate student-athlete must have at least a 3.50 cumulative grade point average (on a 4.0 scale); a graduate student-athlete must have at least a 3.50 cumulative grade point average (on a 4.0 scale) as both an undergraduate and a grad student unless they are in their first semester as a graduate student and don't have an established graduate GPA. Prior to 2022-23, the minimum cumulative grade point average was 3.30.
- 1983 Christopher Kelly, Honorable Mention
- 1983 Tim McGarry, Honorable Mention
- 1992 Russell Turner, First Team
- 1999 David Hobbs, Second Team
- 2004 Brandon Randall, Third Team
- 2024 Adam Brazil, Second Team
- 2025 Adam Brazil, First Team
NABC All-District (4)
- 2023 Davidson Hubbard, Second Team
- 2024 Adam Brazil, First Team
- 2024 Davidson Hubbard, First Team
- 2025 Adam Brazil, First Team
NABC District 6 Player of the Year (1)
- 2025 - Adam Brazil
NABC District 6 Coach of the Year (2)
- 2023 - Caleb Kimbrough
- 2024 - Caleb Kimbrough
NABC Honors Court
- 2024-25 - Adam Brazil
- 2024-25 - Ayman McGowan
- 2024-25 - Colin Radcliffe
NABC Team Academic Excellence Award
- 2024-25
All-Region (22)
- 1988 Ralph Baker
- 1989 Ralph Baker
- 1990 Russell Turner
- 1991 Russell Turner
- 1992 Russell Turner
- 1994 Nate Schwab
- 1995 Nate Schwab
- 1995 Jason Leonard
- 1998 T.J. Grimes
- 1999 T.J. Grimes
- 2000 T.J. Grimes
- 2003 Jeff Monroe
- 2004 Jeff Monroe
- 2011 Harrison George
- 2012 Harrison George
- 2013 Harrison George
- 2014 Khobi Williamson
- 2015 Mike Murray
- 2023 Davidson Hubbard, Second Team (D3hoops.com)
- 2024 Adam Brazil, First Team (D3hoops.com)
- 2024 Davidson Hubbard, First Team (D3hoops.com)
- 2025 Adam Brazil, First Team (D3hoops.com)
D3hoops.com Region 6 Player of the Year (1)
- 2025 Adam Brazil
D3hoops.com Region 6 Coach of the Year (1)
- 2025 Caleb Kimbrough
All-ODAC (86)
- 1977 Ed Tiernan, First
- 1977 Lewis Elliott, Second
- 1978 Ed Owens, First
- 1978 Tom Jackson, Second
- 1979 Ed Owens, First
- 1979 L.F. Elliott, First
- 1979 Tom Jackson, Second
- 1980 Ed Owens, First
- 1980 Bill Shelly, Second
- 1980 Drew Payne, Second
- 1981 Jeff Kroll, First
- 1983 Mark Kelly, First
- 1987 Ralph Baker, Second
- 1988 Ralph Baker, First
- 1989 Ralph Baker, First
- 1989 Russell Turner, First
- 1990 Russell Turner, First
- 1990 Pat Mulquin, Second
- 1991 Russell Turner, First
- 1991 Orson Williams, Second
- 1992 Russell Turner, First
- 1992 Bat Barber, Second
- 1993 Everett Joyner, Second
- 1994 Nate Schwab, First
- 1995 Nate Schwab, First
- 1995 Jason Leonard, Second
- 1996 Ryan Odom, Second
- 1996 Nate Schwab, Second
- 1997 Bryan Sheridan, Second
- 1998 T.J. Grimes, First
- 1999 T.J. Grimes, First
- 1999 Chris Fox, First
- 1999 David Hobbs, Second
- 2000 Chris Fox, Second
- 2000 T.J. Grimes, First
- 2000 Jeremy Harris, Second
- 2000 Jack Jirak, Second
- 2001 Bobby Jackson, Second
- 2002 Brandon Randall, Second
- 2002 Lane Brooks, Honorable Mention
- 2002 Marcus Gregory, Honorable Mention
- 2003 Jeff Monroe, First
- 2003 Lane Brooks, Honorable Mention
- 2003 Marcus Gregory, Honorable Mention
- 2003 Brandon Randall, Honorable Mention
- 2004 Jeff Monroe, First
- 2004 Brandon Randall, Second
- 2004 Mike Thompson, Honorable Mention
- 2004 David Willson, Honorable Mention
- 2005 Drew Prehmus, Honorable Mention
- 2006 Troy Kaase, First
- 2006 Drew Prehmus, Honorable Mention
- 2007 Mike Edwards, Second
- 2007 Drew Prehmus, Honorable Mention
- 2007 Turner King, Honorable Mention
- 2008 Turner King, First
- 2008 Troy Kaase, Second
- 2008 Drew Prehmus, Honorable Mention
- 2009 Turner King, First
- 2010 Turner King, Second
- 2010 Harrison George, Honorable Mention
- 2011 Harrison George, First
- 2012 Harrison George, First
- 2012 Khobi Williamson, Third
- 2013 Harrison George, First
- 2013 Khobi Williamson, First
- 2014 Khobi Williamson, First
- 2015 Mike Murray, Second
- 2016 Mike Murray, Second
- 2017 Jake Duncan, Third
- 2018 Malik Crute, Third
- 2020 Jack Wyatt, Second
- 2020 Jake Hahn, Third
- 2021* Jake Hahn
- 2022 Ryan Clements, Second
- 2023 Davidson Hubbard, First
- 2023 Adam Brazil, Second
- 2023 Ryan Clements, Third
- 2024 Adam Brazil, First
- 2024 Davidson Hubbard, First
- 2024 Ryan Clements, Third
- 2025 Adam Brazil, First
- 2025 Shane Fernald, First
- 2026 Travis Stickney, Second
- 2026 Santana Lynch, Third
- 2026 Peter Moye, Third
*One Team selected for abbreviated season due to COVID-19
Coach of the Year (6)
- Don Thompson (1978)
- Don Thompson (1979)
- Tony Shaver (1995)
- Tony Shaver (1999)
- Tony Shaver (2000)
- Caleb Kimbrough (2023)
Player of the Year (3)
- Russell Turner (1992)
- T.J. Grimes (2000)
- Adam Brazil (2025)
Rookie of the Year (1)
- Harrison George (2010)
Scholar-Athlete of the Year (4)
- Matt Green (2007)
- Drew Prehmus (2008)
- Adam Brazil (2024)
- Adam Brazil (2025)
All-State (17)
- 2004 Jeff Monroe, First
- 2004 Brandon Randall, Honorable Mention
- 2006 Troy Kaase, First
- 2007 Mike Edwards, Second
- 2008 Turner King, First
- 2008 Troy Kaase, Honorable Mention
- 2009 Turner King, First
- 2011 Harrison George, First
- 2012 Harrison George, First
- 2013 Harrison George, First
- 2013 Khobi Williamson, Second
- 2014 Khobi Williamson, Second
- 2023 Davidson Hubbard, Second
- 2024 Adam Brazil, First
- 2024 Davidson Hubbard, First
- 2025 Adam Brazil, First
- 2025 Shane Fernald, Second
Coach of the Year (1)
- Caleb Kimbrough (2024)
Player of the Year (2)
- Davidson Hubbard (2024)
- Adam Brazil (2025)
Rookie of the Year (1)
- Harrison George (2010)
All-Mason Dixon (7)
- 1949 - Bill Balas
- 1950 - Emerson Johnson
- 1953 - Jerry Adam
- 1957 - Leon Hawker
- 1963 - Bill Hardin
- 1965 - Thom Quarles
- 1966 - Eddy Dyer