Most Valuable
- 1986-87: Ralph Baker
- 1987-88: Ralph Baker
- 1988-89: Ralph Baker
- 1989-90: Russell Turner
- 1990-91: Russell Turner
- 1991-92: Russell Turner
- 1993-94: Nate Schwab
- 1994-95: Entire Team
- 1995-96: Ryan Odom
- 1996-97: Bryan Sheridan, Elson DeVan
- 1997-98: T.J. Grimes
- 1998-99: T.J. Grimes
- 1999-00: T.J. Grimes, Chris Fox, Jeremy Harris, Jack Jirak
- 2000-01: Aaron Gibbs
- 2001-02: Marcus Gregory
- 2002-03: Jeff Monroe
- 2003-04: Jeff Monroe
- 2004-05: Drew Prehmus
- 2005-06: Troy Kaase
- 2006-07: Mike Edwards
- 2007-08: Turner King
- 2008-09: Turner King
- 2009-10: Turner King
- 2010-11: Harrison George
- 2011-12: Harrison George
- 2012-13: Harrison George
- 2013-14: Khobi Williamson
- 2014-15: Mike Murray
- 2015-16: Mike Murray
- 2016-17: Jake Duncan
- 2023-24: Davidson Hubbard | Offensive Player of the Year
Leadership Award
- 1986-87: Andy Gray
- 1988-89: Ralph Baker
- 1989-90: Bat Barber
- 1990-91: Orson Williams
- 1991-92: Bat Barber
- 1993-94: Dee Vick, Todd Kerr
- 1994-95: Todd Kerr
- 1995-96: Griff Aldrich
- 1996-97: Elson DeVan
- 1997-98: Ryan Sharp
- 1998-99: David Hobbs, Alex Robbins
- 1999-00: Jeremy Harris
- 2000-01: Kevin Swann
- 2001-02: Brandon Randall
- 2002-03: Brandon Randall
- 2003-04: Brandon Randall, Jeff Monroe, David Willson
- 2004-05: Matt Guill
- 2005-06: Matt Guill, Matt Green
- 2006-07: Matt Green
- 2007-08: Tyler Murray
- 2008-09: Byron Lawton
- 2009-10: Jonathan Mudd
- 2010-11: Colin O'Neill
- 2013-14: Mike Murray
- 2023-24: Adam Brazil | Charlie Cobb SOE Award
Rebounding Award
- 1986-87: Griff Morris
- 1987-88: Pat Mulquinn
- 1988-89: Orson Williams
- 1989-90: Brad Pomeroy
- 1990-91: Orson Williams
- 1991-92: Russell Turner
- 1992-93: Jason Leonard
- 1992-94: Jason Leonard
- 1994-95: Jason Leonard
- 1995-96: Bryan Sheridan
- 1996-97: Bryan Sheridan
- 1997-98: Jeremy Harris
- 1998-99: David Hobbs
- 1999-00: Jack Jirak
- 2000-01: Bobby Jackson
- 2001-02: Lane Brooks
- 2002-03: Lane Brooks
- 2003-04: Mike Thompson
- 2004-05: Aaron Lewek
- 2005-06: Troy Kaase
- 2006-07: Tyler Murray
- 2007-08: Troy Kaase
- 2008-09: Shane Payne
- 2009-10: Harrison George
- 2010-11: Harrison George
- 2011-12: Khobi Williamson
- 2012-13: Harrison George
- 2013-14: Khobi Williamson
- 2014-15: Mike Murray
- 2015-16: Guilherme Guimaraes
- 2016-17: Jake Duncan
- 2017-18: Nick Chase
- 2018-19: Warren Zager
- 2019-20: Jake Hahn
- 2020-21: Jake Hahn
- 2021-22: Davidson Hubbard
- 2022-23: Davidson Hubbard
- 2023-24: Alex Elliott
Assist Award
- 1986-87: Ralph Baker
- 1987-88: Ralph Baker
- 1988-89: Bill Carnohan
- 1989-90: Bat Barber
- 1990-91: Bat Barber
- 1991-92: Bat Barber
- 1992-93: Tee Jennings
- 1993-94: Tee Jennings
- 1994-95: Tee Jennings
- 1995-96: Ryan Odom
- 1996-97: Elson DeVan
- 1997-98: T.J. Grimes
- 1998-99: Alex Robbins
- 1999-00: Chris Fox
- 2000-01: Marcus Gregory
- 2001-02: Marucs Gregory
- 2002-03: Marcus Gregory
- 2003-04: Brian Gunn
- 2004-05: Matt Guill
- 2005-06: Matt Green
- 2006-07: Matt Green
- 2007-08: Byron Lawton
- 2008-09: Byron Lawton
- 2009-10: Ben Jessee
- 2010-11: Randall Ward
- 2011-12: Patrick Corrigan
- 2013-14: Mike Murray
- 2014-15: Mike Murray
- 2015-16: Mike Murray
- 2016-17: Logan Samuels
- 2017-18: Brendan McHale
- 2018-19: Brendan McHale
- 2019-20: Ryan Clements
- 2020-21: Ryan Clements
- 2021-22: Ryan Clements
- 2022-23: Adam Brazil
- 2023-24: Adam Brazil
Free Throw Shooting Award (2.0 made per game)
- 1986-87: Andy Gray
- 1987-88: Pat Mulquin
- 1988-89: Pat Mulquin
- 1989-90: Pat Mulquin
- 1990-91: Pat Mulquin
- 1991-92: Bat Barber
- 1992-93: Ryan Odom
- 1993-94: Nate Schwab
- 1994-95: Nate Schwab
- 1995-96: Ryan Odom
- 1996-97: T.J. Grimes
- 1997-98: Chris Fox
- 1998-99: Chris Fox
- 1999-00: T.J. Grimes
- 2000-01: Brandon Randall
- 2001-02: Lane Brooks
- 2002-03: Brandon Randall
- 2003-04: Mike Edwards
- 2004-05: Drew Prehmus
- 2005-06: Drew Prehmus
- 2006-07: Drew Prehmus
- 2007-08: Drew Prehmus
- 2008-09: Ben Jessee
- 2009-10: Ben Jessee
- 2010-11: Randall Ward
- 2011-12: Ben Jessee
- 2012-13: Mike Murray
- 2013-14: JaVonte Reddick
- 2014-15: Mike Murray
- 2015-16: Nick Chase
- 2016-17: Nick Chase
- 2017-18: Nick Chase
- 2018-19: Chaise Johnson
- 2019-20: Ryan Clements
- 2020-21: Ryan Clements
- 2021-22: Ryan Clements
- 2022-23: Ryan Clements
- 2023-24: Ryan Clements
Three-Point Shooting Award (2.0 made per game)
- 2008-09: Ben Jesse
- 2009-10: Turner King
- 2010-11: Ben Jessee
- 2011-12: Randall Ward
- 2012-13: Greg Lewis
- 2013-14: Greg Lewis
- 2014-15: Greg Lewis
- 2015-16: Jake Duncan
- 2016-17: Jake Duncan
- 2017-18: Kevin Quinn
- 2018-19: Cole Atwood
- 2019-20: Kevin Quinn
- 2020-21: DJ Wright
- 2021-22: Adam Brazil
- 2022-23: Adam Brazil
- 2023-24: Adam Brazil
Defensive Award
- 1989-90: Bill Carnohan
- 1990-91: Bill Carnohan
- 1991-92: Brad Pomeroy
- 1992-93: Tee Jennings
- 1993-94: Tee Jennings
- 1994-95: Tee Jennings
- 1995-96: Kevin Garst
- 1996-97: Elson DeVan
- 1997-98: Kevin Garst
- 1998-99: Kevin Garst
- 1999-00: Chris Fox
- 2000-01: Marcus Gregory
- 2001-02: Marcus Gregory
- 2002-03: Brandon Randall
- 2003-04: Brandon Randall
- 2004-05: Matt Guill
- 2005-06: Matt Guill
- 2006-07: Tyler Murray
- 2007-08: Jyri Laakso
- 2008-09: Shane Payne
- 2009-10: Karlis Trops
- 2010-11: Ru White
- 2011-12: Ru White
- 2012-13: Keegan Wetzel
- 2013-14: Leon Hargrove
- 2014-15: Alex Smith
- 2015-16: JaVonte Reddick
- 2016-17: JaVonte Reddick
- 2023-24: Josiah Hardy
Coaches'Â Award
- 1986-87: Rick Caldwell
- 1987-88: Kasey Carver
- 1988-89: Orson Williams
- 1989-90: Brad Pomeroy
- 1990-91: Steve Musilli
- 1991-92: Greg Bostian
- 1992-93: Joel Benefiel
- 1993-94: Donald Gilliam
- 1994-95: Jason Leonard
- 1995-96: Alex Robbins
- 1996-97: Kevin Garst
- 1997-98: Chris Fox
- 1998-99: Chris Fox, Jeremy Harris
- 1999-00: Chris Fox
- 2000-01: Brandon Randall
- 2001-02: David Willson
- 2002-03: Marcus Gregory
- 2003-04: Jason Holman
- 2004-05: Bill Taylor
- 2005-06: Matt Guill
- 2006-07: Troy Kaase
- 2007-08: Tyler Murray
- 2008-09: Colin O'Neill
- 2009-10: Hakeem Croom
- 2010-11: Sasha Obradovic
- 2011-12: Keegan Wetzel
- 2013-14: Mitch Owens
- 2014-15: William Scott
- 2015-16: Andrew Evans
- 2023-24: Shawn Hodge | Make Your Mark Award
Most Improved Award
- 1986-87: Kasey Carver
- 1987-88: Jack Barber
- 1988-89: Bar Barber
- 1989-90: Steve Musilli
- 1990-91: Drew Wise
- 1991-92: Jason Leonard
- 1992-93: Nate Schwab
- 1993-94: Jason Leonard
- 1994-95: Elson DeVan
- 1995-96: Ryan Sharp
- 1996-97: T.J. Grimes
- 1997-98: Aaron Gibbs
- 1998-99: Brett Thompson
- 1999-00: Mark Brown
- 2000-01: Jeff Monroe
- 2001-02: Jason Holman
- 2002-03: Andy Jackson
- 2003-04: Davis Bowne
- 2004-05: Matt Green
- 2005-06: Jyri Laakso
- 2006-07: Lane Medlin
- 2007-08: Brent Dillard
- 2008-09: Ben Jessee
- 2009-10: Colin O'Neill
- 2010-11: Khobi Williamson
- 2011-12: Leon Hargrove
- 2012-13: Kodie Critzer
- 2013-14: Alex Smith
- 2014-15: Josh Katowitz
- 2015-16: Guilherme Guimaraes
- 2016-17: Hunter Kuehn, Justin Reid
- 2023-24: Shane Fernald
Toughness Award
- 2008-09: Shane Payne
- 2010-11: Ru White
- 2011-12: Khobi Williamson
- 2012-13: Khobi Williamson
- 2013-14: Khobi Williamson
- 2014-15: Logan Samuel
- 2015-16: Guilherme Guimaraes
- 2016-17: Guilherme Guimaraes
Sixth Man/Woman of the Year
- 2008-09: Jason Ferguson, Richard Epperson
- 2011-12: Jim Whitehead
- 2012-13: Byron Wurdeman
- 2014-15: Russell Turner, Krissy Vick
- 2015-16: Kevin Tuck, Jennie Porter
- 2016-17: Dr. Jorge Silveira