Hampden-Sydney College

1. Dan McFarlan
   1. Texas League, 1892
   2.  A,  B, Independent, 1894-1905
   3.  Louisville Colonels (NL), 1895
   4.  Brooklyn Superbas (NL)/Washington Senators (NL), 1899
   5.  Western Pennsylvania League, 1907
2. Harold Dudley '25
   1.  Syracuse (AAA), 1925
3. Clarence (Soup) Campbell, Jr. '35    
   1.  Cleveland Indians, 1940-41
   2.  Baltimore Orioles (AAA), 1946-47
4. W. Birch Douglass Jr. '36    
   1.  Coastal Plain League, 1937-38
   2.  Tar Heel League, 1939
   3.  Southern Association/Piedmont League, 1940
5. Bill Connelly    
   1.  Philadelphia (AL), 1945
   2.  Chicago (AL)/Detroit, 1950
   3.  New York (NL), 1952
   4.  New York (NL), 1953
   5.  A, AA, AAA, 1946-50, 51-57
6. Gladstone Smith '52    
   1.  Canadian-American/Wisconsin State Leagues, 1951
   2.  Wisconsin State League, 1952
   3.  Pennsylvania-Ontario-New York League, 1953
7. Dean Tester '54    
   1.  Appalachian League, 1954
8. Gene Cooke '58    
   1.  Pittsburgh Pirates (Class B), 1958
9. Robert W. (Bobby) Humphreys '58    
   1.  A, AA, AAA, 1958-62
   2.  Detroit Tigers, 1962
   3.  St. Louis Cardinals, 1963-64
   4.  Chicago Cubs, 1965
   5.  Washington Senators, 1966-70
   6.  Milwaukee Brewers, 1970
   7.  Evansville (AAA), 1971
10. Wayne McLean '60    
    1.  Carolina League, 1961
    2.  Northern League, 1962
    3.  Florida State League, 1963
11. Jody Williams '87    
    1.  Watertown (A), 1987
12. Jon Waite '88    
    1.  Huntington (A), 1992
13. John Schoenholtz    
    1.  Continental League (Independent), 2007
14. Jason Bour*    
    1.  Rookie, A-AA, 2007-11
15. Reggie Johnson '16    
    1.  Rookie, A, 2016-17
    2.  Frontier League (Independent), 2018
16. Jonathan Triesler '20    
    1.  Pecos League (Independent), 2021-22
17. Bradford Webb '20    
    1.  Rookie League (Texas Rangers), 2021
    2.  Carolina/South Atlantic/Texas League (Rookie, A, AA), 2022
    3.  South Atlantic League, 2023

*played one season at H-SC (2005)