NCAA Division III Playoff Appearances (7)
- 1977 First Round
- 2007 First Round
- 2009 First Round
- 2010 First Round
- 2011 First Round
- 2013 Second Round
- 2014 First Round
NCAA College Division Playoff Appearances (2)
- 1970 Knute Rockne Bowl (East Region Championship)
- 1971 Knute Rockne Bowl (East Region Championship)
ODAC Championships (9)
- 1977
- 1982
- 1983
- 1987
- 2007
- 2009
- 2011
- 2013
- 2014
Mason-Dixon Conference Championships (10)
- 1953
- 1954
- 1956
- 1957
- 1964
- 1966
- 1970
- 1971
- 1972
- 1973
Gammon Cup
The Gammon Cup is awarded annually to the student-athlete in the graduating class who has best served the College. It is given in memory of Dr. Edgar G. Gammon, former pastor of College Church (1917-23) and President of the College (1939-55), and recipients are considered for their character, scholarship and athletic ability. Please note that the Gammon Cup was not awarded from 1944-46 due to World War II.
Football Recipients (58)
- 1924 Harold J. Dudley
- 1925 E.M. Sager
- 1926 Gordon Clarke
- 1927 A.K. Dudley, Jr.
- 1928 H.S. Myles
- 1929 C.E. Turley
- 1930 R.W. Lawson, Jr.
- 1931 L.L. Price
- 1933 E.J. Nottingham III
- 1934 S.B. McLaughlin
- 1935 R.K. Young, Jr.
- 1936 W.S. Formwalt
- 1937 C.W. McCann
- 1939 W. Taylor Reveley
- 1940 Bennett H. Barnes, Jr.
- 1941 T.G. Offterdinger
- 1942 Walter L. Thurman, Jr.
- 1948 George J. Kostel
- 1951 Alfred A. Adkins III
- 1954 James J. Stokes
- 1955 J. Stokeley Fulton
- 1956 James H. Smith
- 1957 Henry H. McVey III
- 1958 E. Eugene Cooke
- 1960 William T. Wilson
- 1961 George J. McVey
- 1962 Thomas S. Tredway
- 1963 Dennis B. Dills
- 1964 W. Sidney Druen
- 1965 George H. Heilig, Jr.
- 1968 James B. Lee
- 1969 Russell V. Palmore
- 1970 John Daniel Pond II
- 1971 Robbie Woltz
- 1973 Sidney H. Kirstein
- 1974 Bruce Taylor
- 1976 David Paxton
- 1977 Robert D. Parsons
- 1978 William Redd
- 1980 Timothy S. Maxa
- 1984 Dennis Lee, David Jones
- 1985 Frank Wheeler
- 1986 Steven M. Sharp
- 1987 Cap Putt
- 1988 David Kelly, Brett Bennett
- 1990 Stephen Waskey
- 1991 Max Reid
- 1996 Aaron Walters
- 1997 Cory Williams
- 2002 Neal Herndon
- 2003 Jimmy Hicks
- 2004 Conrad Singh
- 2009 Sam Rosten
- 2012 Ben Rogers
- 2013 Alex Price
- 2015 Holton Walker
- 2019 Alec Cobb
- 2021 Tyler Howerton
All-Americans (88)
Selections from American Football Coaches Association, Kodak, Pizza Hut, Champions USA, Hansen's Gazette, Associated Press, usafootball.com, D3football.com and Football News. Bold indicates First Team selections.
- 1930 Lloyd Arehart, E
- 1930 Charlie Garden, FB
- 1935 Bill Formwalt, E
- 1935 Harold White, HB
- 1948 Lynn Chewning, FB
- 1954 J. Stokeley Fulton, C
- 1955 Ron Henry, E
- 1955 John Hodges, OL/DL
- 1955 Bill LeHew, FB
- 1956 Jim Frazer, T
- 1956 Bill LeHew, FB
- 1958 Billy Benson, HB
- 1958 Tommy Davis, QB
- 1958 Jack Harrington, G
- 1958 Bill Richmond, C
- 1959 Jack Harrington, G
- 1959 Charlie Sears, FB
- 1961 Bill Sale, C
- 1961 Bobby Saylor, E
- 1961 Lewis Everett, FB
- 1962 Lewis Everett, FB
- 1963 George Heilig, WB
- 1964 George Heilig, WB
- 1964 Whitey Lipscomb, QB
- 1968 Ray Dodson, DL
- 1969 Lloyd Goode, G
- 1969 Vince Hardy, T
- 1970 Tom Haynie, G
- 1970 Sid Kirstein, DE
- 1970 Mike Leidy, LB
- 1971 Mike Leidy, LB
- 1971 Butch Beverly, DB
- 1971 Sid Kirstein, DE
- 1972 Mike Leidy, LB
- 1972 Sid Kirstein, DE
- 1973 Tracy Powers, RB
- 1974 Ed Keefer, LB
- 1974 Ed Kelly, DE
- 1975 Ed Kelly, DE
- 1977 Bob Wilson, T
- 1977 Jimmy Ferguson, RB
- 1977 Ben Newell, WR
- 1978 Tim Smith, DT
- 1980 Scott Moorhead, WR
- 1983 Phil Suazo, DB
- 1984 Phil Suazo, DB
- 1986 Jimmy Hondroulis, PK
- 1986 David Kelly, FB
- 1988 Stephen Waskey, WR
- 1989 Stephen Waskey, WR
- 1991 John Lavalle, TE
- 1991 Dwayne Bowyer, QB
- 1991 Greg Hatfield, NG
- 1991 Jay Hicks, WR
- 1992 Curtis Turner, DB
- 1992 Greg Hatfield, NG
- 1993 Mark Hazelwood, LB
- 1993 Matt Kerry, G
- 2000 Matt Romani, T
- 2000 Christ Scott, DB
- 2000 Jeff Woody, WR
- 2002 Chris Scott, DB
- 2003 Conrad Singh, WR
- 2003 Lee Bailey, C
- 2003 CW Clemmons, RB
- 2005 Ben Dull, TE
- 2005 J.D. Ricca, QB
- 2005 Zeke Traylor, G
- 2007 Drew Smith, WR
- 2009 Bill Doody, S
- 2009 Will Riggenbach, DE
- 2009 Andrew Sellers, LB
- 2010 Bill Doody, S
- 2010 Trevor Ikwild, LB
- 2010 David Prizzia, PK
- 2010 Will Riggenbach, DE
- 2011 Ben Rogers, C
- 2011 Kyle Vance, WR
- 2011 Zach Morgan, CB
- 2012 Will Ferrell, T
- 2013 Tyler Ikwild, LB
- 2013 Nash Nance, QB
- 2013 Holton Walker, WR
- 2014 Holton Walker, WR
- 2017 Cam Johnson, WR
- 2020 Ed Newman, TE (Spring 2021)
- 2022 Will Pickren, S
- 2023 Will Pickren, S
CoSIDA/CSC Academic All-Americans (13)
The College Sports Information Directors of America (CoSIDA) began the Academic All-America program in 1952. The organization is now known as College Sports Communicators (CSC). To be eligible for this prestigious award: student-athletes must be at least a sophomore academically and athletically; student-athletes must be enrolled at their institution at the time of nomination either as undergraduates or graduate students. Only the school at which an athlete competed in the current academic year can nominate that player; an undergraduate student-athlete must have at least a 3.50 cumulative grade point average (on a 4.0 scale); a graduate student-athlete must have at least a 3.50 cumulative grade point average (on a 4.0 scale) as both an undergraduate and a grad student unless they are in their first semester as a graduate student and don't have an established graduate GPA. Prior to 2022-23, the minimum cumulative grade point average was 3.30
- 1982 John Dickinson, First Team
- 1982 Hiter Harris, Second Team
- 1984 Brad Cary, Second Team
- 1989 T.C. Wilson, Second Team
- 1989 W.R. Jones, Second Team
- 1990 W.R. Jones, First Team
- 1991 David Brickhill, First Team
- 1996 Cory Williams, Second Team
- 2003 Conrad Singh, Second Team
- 2009 Josh Miller, Second Team
- 2019 Tyler Howerton, First Team
- 2019 Rhett Andersen, Second Team
- 2020 Tyler Howerton, First Team (Spring 2021)